Двусторонняя монополия: почему проблема важна для России и при чем здесь антитраст?

17 января 2019, 14:00 – 15:30, Корпус 2, 0 этаж, Аудитория 018

Применение антимонопольного законодательства в ситуациях, когда на рынке существует монополия или монопсония – довольно рутинная практика. Но если они сочетаются – то есть на рынке одновременно действует только один продавец и только один покупатель, насколько применимы здесь традиционные подходы к анализу, может ли антитраст эффективно справиться с такой проблемой и должен ли вообще антитраст заниматься ситуацией двусторонней монополии? Подобные вопросы особенно важны, если исходить из того, что двусторонняя монополия – это не просто сумма монополии и монопсонии.

Вопросы для обсуждения

  • Целесообразно ли вмешательство третьей стороны (суд, антимонопольный орган) во взаимоотношения монополиста и монопсониста на рынке двусторонней монополии?
  • Если антимонопольный орган сравнительно более эффективно решает проблемы двусторонней монополии, по какой модели он лучше это делает?
  • Каковы подходы в анализе двусторонней монополии с точки зрения «техники»?
  • Как антимонопольный орган может и должен повлиять на баланс переговорной силы участников рынка, обращающихся к нему в попытке перераспределения ожидаемых выигрышей и издержек от переговоров?

Модераторы

  • Андрей Шаститко
    Андрей Шаститко

    директор Центра исследований конкуренции и экономического регулирования РАНХиГС

  • Андрей Цыганов
    Андрей Цыганов

    заместитель руководителя Федеральной антимонопольной службы

Участники

  • Андрей Цариковский
    Андрей Цариковский

    статс-секретарь, заместитель руководителя Федеральной антимонопольной службы

  • Кирилл Дозмаров
    Кирилл Дозмаров

    адвокат, руководитель группы антимонопольной практики Art de Lex

  • Мария Рожнова
    Мария Рожнова

    старший юрист, руководитель направления «Антимонопольное и торговое законодательство» АО «Данон Россия»

  • Наталья Павлова
    Наталья Павлова

    заместитель директора Центра исследований конкуренции и экономического регулирования РАНХиГС

  • Нелли Галимханова
    Нелли Галимханова

    начальник Управления контроля промышленности Федеральной антимонопольной службы

Array
(
    [ACTIVE_TO] => 17.01.2019 15:30:00
    [~ACTIVE_TO] => 17.01.2019 15:30:00
    [ACTIVE_FROM] => 17.01.2019 14:00:00
    [~ACTIVE_FROM] => 17.01.2019 14:00:00
    [ID] => 14937
    [~ID] => 14937
    [NAME] => Двусторонняя монополия: почему проблема важна для России и при чем здесь антитраст?
    [~NAME] => Двусторонняя монополия: почему проблема важна для России и при чем здесь антитраст?
    [IBLOCK_ID] => 9
    [~IBLOCK_ID] => 9
    [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 254
    [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 254
    [DETAIL_TEXT] => 
    [~DETAIL_TEXT] => 
    [DETAIL_TEXT_TYPE] => html
    [~DETAIL_TEXT_TYPE] => html
    [PREVIEW_TEXT] => 

Применение антимонопольного законодательства в ситуациях, когда на рынке существует монополия или монопсония – довольно рутинная практика. Но если они сочетаются – то есть на рынке одновременно действует только один продавец и только один покупатель, насколько применимы здесь традиционные подходы к анализу, может ли антитраст эффективно справиться с такой проблемой и должен ли вообще антитраст заниматься ситуацией двусторонней монополии? Подобные вопросы особенно важны, если исходить из того, что двусторонняя монополия – это не просто сумма монополии и монопсонии.

[~PREVIEW_TEXT] =>

Применение антимонопольного законодательства в ситуациях, когда на рынке существует монополия или монопсония – довольно рутинная практика. Но если они сочетаются – то есть на рынке одновременно действует только один продавец и только один покупатель, насколько применимы здесь традиционные подходы к анализу, может ли антитраст эффективно справиться с такой проблемой и должен ли вообще антитраст заниматься ситуацией двусторонней монополии? Подобные вопросы особенно важны, если исходить из того, что двусторонняя монополия – это не просто сумма монополии и монопсонии.

[PREVIEW_TEXT_TYPE] => html [~PREVIEW_TEXT_TYPE] => html [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [TIMESTAMP_X] => 17.05.2019 17:08:32 [~TIMESTAMP_X] => 17.05.2019 17:08:32 [LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [~LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /program/17-yanvarya/dvustoronnyaya-monopoliya-pochemu-problema-vazhna-dlya-rossii-i-prichem-zdes-antitrast/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /program/17-yanvarya/dvustoronnyaya-monopoliya-pochemu-problema-vazhna-dlya-rossii-i-prichem-zdes-antitrast/ [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => dvustoronnyaya-monopoliya-pochemu-problema-vazhna-dlya-rossii-i-prichem-zdes-antitrast [~CODE] => dvustoronnyaya-monopoliya-pochemu-problema-vazhna-dlya-rossii-i-prichem-zdes-antitrast [EXTERNAL_ID] => 14937 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 14937 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => program [~IBLOCK_CODE] => program [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 9 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 9 [LID] => s1 [~LID] => s1 [NAV_RESULT] => [DISPLAY_ACTIVE_FROM] => 17 Января 2019 [IPROPERTY_VALUES] => Array ( ) [FIELDS] => Array ( [ACTIVE_TO] => 17.01.2019 15:30:00 [ACTIVE_FROM] => 17.01.2019 14:00:00 ) [PROPERTIES] => Array ( [QUESTIONS] => Array ( [ID] => 12 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-18 10:54:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 10 [CODE] => QUESTIONS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 12 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => HTML [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array ( [height] => 200 ) [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 73909 [VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => <ul class="style-prog-list"> <li>Целесообразно ли вмешательство третьей стороны (суд, антимонопольный орган) во взаимоотношения монополиста и монопсониста на рынке двусторонней монополии? </li> <li>Если антимонопольный орган сравнительно более эффективно решает проблемы двусторонней монополии, по какой модели он лучше это делает?</li> <li> Каковы подходы в анализе двусторонней монополии с точки зрения «техники»?</li> <li> Как антимонопольный орган может и должен повлиять на баланс переговорной силы участников рынка, обращающихся к нему в попытке перераспределения ожидаемых выигрышей и издержек от переговоров?</li> </ul> [TYPE] => HTML ) [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] =>
  • Целесообразно ли вмешательство третьей стороны (суд, антимонопольный орган) во взаимоотношения монополиста и монопсониста на рынке двусторонней монополии?
  • Если антимонопольный орган сравнительно более эффективно решает проблемы двусторонней монополии, по какой модели он лучше это делает?
  • Каковы подходы в анализе двусторонней монополии с точки зрения «техники»?
  • Как антимонопольный орган может и должен повлиять на баланс переговорной силы участников рынка, обращающихся к нему в попытке перераспределения ожидаемых выигрышей и издержек от переговоров?
[TYPE] => HTML ) [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) ) [TYPE] => Array ( [ID] => 13 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-18 10:54:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Тип мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 20 [CODE] => TYPE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 13 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 110062 [VALUE] => Экспертная дискуссия [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => Экспертная дискуссия [VALUE_XML_ID] => 2 [VALUE_SORT] => 200 [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => 2 [~VALUE] => Экспертная дискуссия [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Тип мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [LOCATION] => Array ( [ID] => 19 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-18 10:54:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 30 [CODE] => LOCATION [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 19 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 73912 [VALUE] => Корпус 2, 0 этаж, Аудитория 018 [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Корпус 2, 0 этаж, Аудитория 018 [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MODERATORS] => Array ( [ID] => 14 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-18 13:54:45 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Модераторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 40 [CODE] => MODERATORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 14 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 73911 [1] => 81228 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Array ( [ID] => 2197 [NAME] => Андрей Шаститко [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-shastitko/ [POSITION] => директор Центра исследований конкуренции и экономического регулирования РАНХиГС [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 3534 ) [1] => Array ( [ID] => 15201 [NAME] => Андрей Цыганов [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-tsyganov/ [POSITION] => заместитель руководителя Федеральной антимонопольной службы [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36712 ) ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 2197 [1] => 15201 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => ) [~NAME] => Модераторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYREPORTS] => Array ( [ID] => 65 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Ключевой доклад / Ключевые доклады [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 50 [CODE] => KEYREPORTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 65 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Ключевой доклад / Ключевые доклады [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYREPORT2S] => Array ( [ID] => 283 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2019-01-04 22:39:47 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Ключевые выступления [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 55 [CODE] => KEYREPORT2S [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Ключевые выступления [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [PARTICIPANTS] => Array ( [ID] => 15 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-18 10:54:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Экcперты [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 60 [CODE] => PARTICIPANTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 15 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Экcперты [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MEMBERS] => Array ( [ID] => 66 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Участники [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 70 [CODE] => MEMBERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 66 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 80148 [1] => 80149 [2] => 80150 [3] => 80151 [4] => 81229 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Array ( [ID] => 15293 [NAME] => Андрей Цариковский [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-tsarikovskiy/ [POSITION] => статс-секретарь, заместитель руководителя Федеральной антимонопольной службы [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36193 ) [1] => Array ( [ID] => 15694 [NAME] => Кирилл Дозмаров [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/kirill-dozmarov/ [POSITION] => адвокат, руководитель группы антимонопольной практики Art de Lex [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36907 ) [2] => Array ( [ID] => 15733 [NAME] => Мария Рожнова [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/mariya-rozhnova/ [POSITION] => старший юрист, руководитель направления «Антимонопольное и торговое законодательство» АО «Данон Россия» [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36722 ) [3] => Array ( [ID] => 15691 [NAME] => Наталья Павлова [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/natalya-pavlova/ [POSITION] => заместитель директора Центра исследований конкуренции и экономического регулирования РАНХиГС [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36686 ) [4] => Array ( [ID] => 15692 [NAME] => Нелли Галимханова [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nelli-galimkhanova/ [POSITION] => начальник Управления контроля промышленности Федеральной антимонопольной службы [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36749 ) ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 15293 [1] => 15694 [2] => 15733 [3] => 15691 [4] => 15692 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => ) [~NAME] => Участники [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS] => Array ( [ID] => 71 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Участники и эксперты [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 80 [CODE] => MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 71 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Участники и эксперты [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYREPORT_MODERATOR] => Array ( [ID] => 73 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Ключевой доклад / модератор [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 90 [CODE] => KEYREPORT_MODERATOR [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 73 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Ключевой доклад / модератор [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SAY_HIS] => Array ( [ID] => 245 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Приветствие [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 91 [CODE] => SAY_HIS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 245 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Приветствие [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SPEECH] => Array ( [ID] => 77 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Выступления [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 100 [CODE] => SPEECH [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 77 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Выступления [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [DISCUSS_MEMBERS] => Array ( [ID] => 219 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Участники дискуссии [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 101 [CODE] => DISCUSS_MEMBERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 219 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Участники дискуссии [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [AUTHORS] => Array ( [ID] => 220 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Авторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 102 [CODE] => AUTHORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 220 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Авторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [LECTORS] => Array ( [ID] => 221 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Лекторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 103 [CODE] => LECTORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 221 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Лекторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [PRESENTATIONS] => Array ( [ID] => 217 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Презентация [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 104 [CODE] => PRESENTATIONS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 217 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Презентация [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SPEAKERS] => Array ( [ID] => 231 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Спикеры [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 105 [CODE] => SPEAKERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 231 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Спикеры [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [OPENINGS] => Array ( [ID] => 240 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Открытие [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 106 [CODE] => OPENINGS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 240 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Открытие [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SUBTITLE] => Array ( [ID] => 75 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Подзаголовок [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 110 [CODE] => SUBTITLE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 75 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Подзаголовок [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MSP_REPRESENTATIVES] => Array ( [ID] => 76 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Представители МСП [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 120 [CODE] => MSP_REPRESENTATIVES [DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 76 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => HTML [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array ( [height] => 200 ) [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Представители МСП [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) ) [MEDIA_LINK] => Array ( [ID] => 118 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Медиаматериалы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 130 [CODE] => MEDIA_LINK [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 118 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 29 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Медиаматериалы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [CALENDAR] => Array ( [ID] => 128 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Календарь [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 140 [CODE] => CALENDAR [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 128 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 110063 [VALUE] => Да [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => Да [VALUE_XML_ID] => 82585f2fc76231ff8c5a3de635aaa8f0 [VALUE_SORT] => 500 [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => 36 [~VALUE] => Да [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Календарь [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [EVENT_INFO] => Array ( [ID] => 129 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Информационное событие [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 150 [CODE] => EVENT_INFO [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 129 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Информационное событие [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [CHANGE] => Array ( [ID] => 130 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Изменение [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 160 [CODE] => CHANGE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 130 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Изменение [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [LANGUAGES] => Array ( [ID] => 222 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Рабочие языки [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 170 [CODE] => LANGUAGES [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 222 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 110064 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => русский ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => Array ( [0] => русский ) [VALUE_XML_ID] => Array ( [0] => 1 ) [VALUE_SORT] => Array ( [0] => 10 ) [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => Array ( [0] => 50 ) [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => русский ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [~NAME] => Рабочие языки [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [INVITATION_ONLY] => Array ( [ID] => 223 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Вход по индивидуальным приглашениям [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 180 [CODE] => INVITATION_ONLY [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 223 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вход по индивидуальным приглашениям [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [PREMIUM_ONLY] => Array ( [ID] => 232 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Вход с бэйджами категории «ПРЕМИУМ» [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 500 [CODE] => PREMIUM_ONLY [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 232 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вход с бэйджами категории «ПРЕМИУМ» [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYNOTE_FILE] => Array ( [ID] => 234 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2019-01-14 21:27:15 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Доклад [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 500 [CODE] => KEYNOTE_FILE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => F [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 234 [FILE_TYPE] => pdf [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Доклад [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) ) [DISPLAY_PROPERTIES] => Array ( [QUESTIONS] => Array ( [ID] => 12 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-18 10:54:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 10 [CODE] => QUESTIONS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 12 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => HTML [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array ( [height] => 200 ) [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 73909 [VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => <ul class="style-prog-list"> <li>Целесообразно ли вмешательство третьей стороны (суд, антимонопольный орган) во взаимоотношения монополиста и монопсониста на рынке двусторонней монополии? </li> <li>Если антимонопольный орган сравнительно более эффективно решает проблемы двусторонней монополии, по какой модели он лучше это делает?</li> <li> Каковы подходы в анализе двусторонней монополии с точки зрения «техники»?</li> <li> Как антимонопольный орган может и должен повлиять на баланс переговорной силы участников рынка, обращающихся к нему в попытке перераспределения ожидаемых выигрышей и издержек от переговоров?</li> </ul> [TYPE] => HTML ) [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] =>
  • Целесообразно ли вмешательство третьей стороны (суд, антимонопольный орган) во взаимоотношения монополиста и монопсониста на рынке двусторонней монополии?
  • Если антимонопольный орган сравнительно более эффективно решает проблемы двусторонней монополии, по какой модели он лучше это делает?
  • Каковы подходы в анализе двусторонней монополии с точки зрения «техники»?
  • Как антимонопольный орган может и должен повлиять на баланс переговорной силы участников рынка, обращающихся к нему в попытке перераспределения ожидаемых выигрышей и издержек от переговоров?
[TYPE] => HTML ) [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [DISPLAY_VALUE] =>
  • Целесообразно ли вмешательство третьей стороны (суд, антимонопольный орган) во взаимоотношения монополиста и монопсониста на рынке двусторонней монополии?
  • Если антимонопольный орган сравнительно более эффективно решает проблемы двусторонней монополии, по какой модели он лучше это делает?
  • Каковы подходы в анализе двусторонней монополии с точки зрения «техники»?
  • Как антимонопольный орган может и должен повлиять на баланс переговорной силы участников рынка, обращающихся к нему в попытке перераспределения ожидаемых выигрышей и издержек от переговоров?
) [LOCATION] => Array ( [ID] => 19 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-18 10:54:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 30 [CODE] => LOCATION [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 19 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 73912 [VALUE] => Корпус 2, 0 этаж, Аудитория 018 [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Корпус 2, 0 этаж, Аудитория 018 [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => [DISPLAY_VALUE] => Корпус 2, 0 этаж, Аудитория 018 ) [MODERATORS] => Array ( [ID] => 14 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-18 13:54:45 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Модераторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 40 [CODE] => MODERATORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 14 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 73911 [1] => 81228 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 2197 [1] => 15201 ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 2197 [1] => 15201 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => ) [~NAME] => Модераторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => [DISPLAY_VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Андрей Шаститко [1] => Андрей Цыганов ) [LINK_ELEMENT_VALUE] => Array ( [2197] => Array ( [ID] => 2197 [~ID] => 2197 [IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [NAME] => Андрей Шаститко [~NAME] => Андрей Шаститко [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-shastitko/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-shastitko/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 3534 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 3534 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => andrey-shastitko [~CODE] => andrey-shastitko [EXTERNAL_ID] => 2197 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 2197 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 166 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 166 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [LID] => s1 [~LID] => s1 ) [15201] => Array ( [ID] => 15201 [~ID] => 15201 [IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [NAME] => Андрей Цыганов [~NAME] => Андрей Цыганов [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-tsyganov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-tsyganov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36712 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36712 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => andrey-tsyganov [~CODE] => andrey-tsyganov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 15201 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 15201 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [LID] => s1 [~LID] => s1 ) ) ) [MEMBERS] => Array ( [ID] => 66 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-12-13 12:17:20 [IBLOCK_ID] => 9 [NAME] => Участники [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 70 [CODE] => MEMBERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 66 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 80148 [1] => 80149 [2] => 80150 [3] => 80151 [4] => 81229 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 15293 [1] => 15694 [2] => 15733 [3] => 15691 [4] => 15692 ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 15293 [1] => 15694 [2] => 15733 [3] => 15691 [4] => 15692 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => ) [~NAME] => Участники [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => [DISPLAY_VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Андрей Цариковский [1] => Кирилл Дозмаров [2] => Мария Рожнова [3] => Наталья Павлова [4] => Нелли Галимханова ) [LINK_ELEMENT_VALUE] => Array ( [15293] => Array ( [ID] => 15293 [~ID] => 15293 [IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [NAME] => Андрей Цариковский [~NAME] => Андрей Цариковский [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-tsarikovskiy/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-tsarikovskiy/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36193 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36193 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => andrey-tsarikovskiy [~CODE] => andrey-tsarikovskiy [EXTERNAL_ID] => 15293 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 15293 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [LID] => s1 [~LID] => s1 ) [15694] => Array ( [ID] => 15694 [~ID] => 15694 [IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [NAME] => Кирилл Дозмаров [~NAME] => Кирилл Дозмаров [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/kirill-dozmarov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/kirill-dozmarov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36907 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36907 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => kirill-dozmarov [~CODE] => kirill-dozmarov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 15694 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 15694 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [LID] => s1 [~LID] => s1 ) [15733] => Array ( [ID] => 15733 [~ID] => 15733 [IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [NAME] => Мария Рожнова [~NAME] => Мария Рожнова [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/mariya-rozhnova/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/mariya-rozhnova/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36722 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36722 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => mariya-rozhnova [~CODE] => mariya-rozhnova [EXTERNAL_ID] => 15733 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 15733 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [LID] => s1 [~LID] => s1 ) [15691] => Array ( [ID] => 15691 [~ID] => 15691 [IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [NAME] => Наталья Павлова [~NAME] => Наталья Павлова [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/natalya-pavlova/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/natalya-pavlova/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36686 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36686 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => natalya-pavlova [~CODE] => natalya-pavlova [EXTERNAL_ID] => 15691 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 15691 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [LID] => s1 [~LID] => s1 ) [15692] => Array ( [ID] => 15692 [~ID] => 15692 [IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [NAME] => Нелли Галимханова [~NAME] => Нелли Галимханова [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nelli-galimkhanova/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nelli-galimkhanova/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36749 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 36749 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => nelli-galimkhanova [~CODE] => nelli-galimkhanova [EXTERNAL_ID] => 15692 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 15692 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 247 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 8 [LID] => s1 [~LID] => s1 ) ) ) ) [IBLOCK] => Array ( [ID] => 9 [~ID] => 9 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 16.01.2019 22:26:55 [~TIMESTAMP_X] => 16.01.2019 22:26:55 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [LID] => s1 [~LID] => s1 [CODE] => program [~CODE] => program [NAME] => Программа форума [~NAME] => Программа форума [ACTIVE] => Y [~ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 90 [~SORT] => 90 [LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [~LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/#ELEMENT_CODE#/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/#ELEMENT_CODE#/ [SECTION_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/ [~SECTION_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/ [CANONICAL_PAGE_URL] => [~CANONICAL_PAGE_URL] => [PICTURE] => [~PICTURE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [DESCRIPTION_TYPE] => text [~DESCRIPTION_TYPE] => text [RSS_TTL] => 24 [~RSS_TTL] => 24 [RSS_ACTIVE] => Y [~RSS_ACTIVE] => Y [RSS_FILE_ACTIVE] => N [~RSS_FILE_ACTIVE] => N [RSS_FILE_LIMIT] => [~RSS_FILE_LIMIT] => [RSS_FILE_DAYS] => [~RSS_FILE_DAYS] => [RSS_YANDEX_ACTIVE] => N [~RSS_YANDEX_ACTIVE] => N [XML_ID] => 9 [~XML_ID] => 9 [TMP_ID] => d409e39726e45c1945623e5d08f8fafe [~TMP_ID] => d409e39726e45c1945623e5d08f8fafe [INDEX_ELEMENT] => Y [~INDEX_ELEMENT] => Y [INDEX_SECTION] => Y [~INDEX_SECTION] => Y [WORKFLOW] => N [~WORKFLOW] => N [BIZPROC] => N [~BIZPROC] => N [SECTION_CHOOSER] => L [~SECTION_CHOOSER] => L [LIST_MODE] => C [~LIST_MODE] => C [RIGHTS_MODE] => S [~RIGHTS_MODE] => S [SECTION_PROPERTY] => N [~SECTION_PROPERTY] => N [PROPERTY_INDEX] => N [~PROPERTY_INDEX] => N [VERSION] => 1 [~VERSION] => 1 [LAST_CONV_ELEMENT] => 0 [~LAST_CONV_ELEMENT] => 0 [SOCNET_GROUP_ID] => [~SOCNET_GROUP_ID] => [EDIT_FILE_BEFORE] => [~EDIT_FILE_BEFORE] => [EDIT_FILE_AFTER] => [~EDIT_FILE_AFTER] => [SECTIONS_NAME] => Разделы [~SECTIONS_NAME] => Разделы [SECTION_NAME] => Раздел [~SECTION_NAME] => Раздел [ELEMENTS_NAME] => Элементы [~ELEMENTS_NAME] => Элементы [ELEMENT_NAME] => Элемент [~ELEMENT_NAME] => Элемент [EXTERNAL_ID] => 9 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 9 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [SERVER_NAME] => gaidarforum.ru [~SERVER_NAME] => gaidarforum.ru ) [SECTION] => Array ( [PATH] => Array ( ) ) [SECTION_URL] => [META_TAGS] => Array ( [TITLE] => Двусторонняя монополия: почему проблема важна для России и при чем здесь антитраст? [ELEMENT_CHAIN] => Двусторонняя монополия: почему проблема важна для России и при чем здесь антитраст? [BROWSER_TITLE] => [KEYWORDS] => [DESCRIPTION] => ) [EXPERTSTYPES] => Array ( [0] => OPENINGS [1] => SAY_HIS [2] => MODERATORS [3] => KEYREPORT_MODERATOR [4] => KEYREPORTS [5] => KEYREPORT2S [6] => SPEAKERS [7] => SPEECH [8] => PRESENTATIONS [9] => MEMBERS [10] => PARTICIPANTS [11] => MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS [12] => DISCUSS_MEMBERS [13] => AUTHORS [14] => LECTORS ) [DATE_EVENT] => 17 января 2019 [START_TIME] => 14:00 [END_TIME] => 15:30 [TIME_EVENT] => 17 января [OGDESC] =>

Применение антимонопольного законодательства в ситуациях, когда на рынке существует монополия или монопсония – довольно рутинная практика. Но если они сочетаются – то есть на рынке одновременно действует только один продавец и только один покупатель, насколько применимы здесь традиционные подходы к анализу, может ли антитраст эффективно справиться с такой проблемой и должен ли вообще антитраст заниматься ситуацией двусторонней монополии? Подобные вопросы особенно важны, если исходить из того, что двусторонняя монополия – это не просто сумма монополии и монопсонии.

)