January 15, 2019, 09:30 – 11:00, Building 6, Floor 1, Small Assembly Hall
Share
This discussion is dedicated to Russian and US income inequality two papers presented: one by Filip Novokmet, Thomas Piketty, and Gabriel Zucman (July 2017), “From Soviets to Oligarchs: Inequality and Property in Russia 1905-2016;” and the other, “American Exceptionalism in Market Income Inequality: An Analysis Based on Microdata from the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) Database,” by Janet C. Gornick, Branko Milanovic, and Nathaniel Johnson (March 2017). One looks at inequality over a very long period, while the other looks at the roots of US "exceptionalism" through the prism of high inequality in the past 30 years.
Issues for Discussion
Are both the US and Russia basically high inequality countries?
Do the presented papers provide a credible understanding of income inequality in Russia in the past and at the current moment?
How well do the authors’ data on Russia reflect real living conditions in the regions?
Why did a higher level of social inequality, in comparison with OECD countries, develop in the US?
How well do historical data for Russia compare with historical data for European countries?
Array
(
[ACTIVE_TO] => 01/15/2019 11:00:00 am
[~ACTIVE_TO] => 01/15/2019 11:00:00 am
[ACTIVE_FROM] => 01/15/2019 09:30:00 am
[~ACTIVE_FROM] => 01/15/2019 09:30:00 am
[ID] => 14981
[~ID] => 14981
[NAME] => INCOME INEQUALITY IN A HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
[~NAME] => INCOME INEQUALITY IN A HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[~IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 302
[~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 302
[DETAIL_TEXT] =>
This discussion is dedicated to Russian and US income inequality two papers presented: one by Filip Novokmet, Thomas Piketty, and Gabriel Zucman (July 2017), “From Soviets to Oligarchs: Inequality and Property in Russia 1905-2016;” and the other, “American Exceptionalism in Market Income Inequality: An Analysis Based on Microdata from the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) Database,” by Janet C. Gornick, Branko Milanovic, and Nathaniel Johnson (March 2017). One looks at inequality over a very long period, while the other looks at the roots of US "exceptionalism" through the prism of high inequality in the past 30 years.
[~DETAIL_TEXT] =>
This discussion is dedicated to Russian and US income inequality two papers presented: one by Filip Novokmet, Thomas Piketty, and Gabriel Zucman (July 2017), “From Soviets to Oligarchs: Inequality and Property in Russia 1905-2016;” and the other, “American Exceptionalism in Market Income Inequality: An Analysis Based on Microdata from the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) Database,” by Janet C. Gornick, Branko Milanovic, and Nathaniel Johnson (March 2017). One looks at inequality over a very long period, while the other looks at the roots of US "exceptionalism" through the prism of high inequality in the past 30 years.
[DETAIL_TEXT_TYPE] => html
[~DETAIL_TEXT_TYPE] => html
[PREVIEW_TEXT] =>
This discussion is dedicated to Russian and US income inequality two papers presented: one by Filip Novokmet, Thomas Piketty, and Gabriel Zucman (July 2017), “From Soviets to Oligarchs: Inequality and Property in Russia 1905-2016;” and the other, “American Exceptionalism in Market Income Inequality: An Analysis Based on Microdata from the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) Database,” by Janet C. Gornick, Branko Milanovic, and Nathaniel Johnson (March 2017). One looks at inequality over a very long period, while the other looks at the roots of US "exceptionalism" through the prism of high inequality in the past 30 years.
[~PREVIEW_TEXT] =>
This discussion is dedicated to Russian and US income inequality two papers presented: one by Filip Novokmet, Thomas Piketty, and Gabriel Zucman (July 2017), “From Soviets to Oligarchs: Inequality and Property in Russia 1905-2016;” and the other, “American Exceptionalism in Market Income Inequality: An Analysis Based on Microdata from the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) Database,” by Janet C. Gornick, Branko Milanovic, and Nathaniel Johnson (March 2017). One looks at inequality over a very long period, while the other looks at the roots of US "exceptionalism" through the prism of high inequality in the past 30 years.
[PREVIEW_TEXT_TYPE] => html
[~PREVIEW_TEXT_TYPE] => html
[DETAIL_PICTURE] =>
[~DETAIL_PICTURE] =>
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/14/2019 12:51:25 pm
[~TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/14/2019 12:51:25 pm
[LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/
[~LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /program/15-january/income-inequality-in-historical-perspective/
[~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /program/15-january/income-inequality-in-historical-perspective/
[LANG_DIR] => /
[~LANG_DIR] => /
[CODE] => income-inequality-in-historical-perspective
[~CODE] => income-inequality-in-historical-perspective
[EXTERNAL_ID] => 14981
[~EXTERNAL_ID] => 14981
[IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content
[~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content
[IBLOCK_CODE] => program
[~IBLOCK_CODE] => program
[IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 900
[~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 900
[LID] => en
[~LID] => en
[NAV_RESULT] =>
[DISPLAY_ACTIVE_FROM] => 15 January 2019
[IPROPERTY_VALUES] => Array
(
)
[FIELDS] => Array
(
[ACTIVE_TO] => 01/15/2019 11:00:00 am
[ACTIVE_FROM] => 01/15/2019 09:30:00 am
)
[PROPERTIES] => Array
(
[QUESTIONS] => Array
(
[ID] => 50
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 10
[CODE] => QUESTIONS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array
(
[TYPE] => HTML
[TEXT] =>
)
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => S
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] => 12
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] => HTML
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array
(
[height] => 200
)
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 74361
[VALUE] => Array
(
[TEXT] => <ul class="style-prog-list">
<li>Are both the US and Russia basically high inequality countries?</li>
<li>Do the presented papers provide a credible understanding of income inequality in Russia in the past and at the current moment?</li>
<li>How well do the authors’ data on Russia reflect real living conditions in the regions?</li>
<li>Why did a higher level of social inequality, in comparison with OECD countries, develop in the US?</li>
<li>How well do historical data for Russia compare with historical data for European countries?</li>
</ul>
[TYPE] => HTML
)
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] => Array
(
[TEXT] =>
Are both the US and Russia basically high inequality countries?
Do the presented papers provide a credible understanding of income inequality in Russia in the past and at the current moment?
How well do the authors’ data on Russia reflect real living conditions in the regions?
Why did a higher level of social inequality, in comparison with OECD countries, develop in the US?
How well do historical data for Russia compare with historical data for European countries?
[TYPE] => HTML
)
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array
(
[TYPE] => HTML
[TEXT] =>
)
)
[TYPE] => Array
(
[ID] => 51
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Тип мероприятия
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 20
[CODE] => TYPE
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => L
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] => 13
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 94764
[VALUE] => Expert Discussion
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] => Expert Discussion
[VALUE_XML_ID] => 2
[VALUE_SORT] => 200
[VALUE_ENUM_ID] => 7
[~VALUE] => Expert Discussion
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Тип мероприятия
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[LOCATION] => Array
(
[ID] => 54
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 30
[CODE] => LOCATION
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => S
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] => 19
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 74363
[VALUE] => Building 6, Floor 1, Small Assembly Hall
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] => Building 6, Floor 1, Small Assembly Hall
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[MODERATORS] => Array
(
[ID] => 52
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:15:56
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Модераторы
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 40
[CODE] => MODERATORS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] => 14
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array
(
[0] => 74661
[1] => 87661
)
[VALUE] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[ID] => 1156
[NAME] => Branko Milanović
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/milanovic-branko/
[POSITION] => Professor, City University of New York; Senior Scholar, Luxembourg Income Study
[DONOTLINK] =>
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 686
)
[1] => Array
(
[ID] => 1154
[NAME] => Carol Scott Leonard
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/carol-leonard/
[POSITION] => Professor, RANEPA
[DONOTLINK] =>
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 684
)
)
[DESCRIPTION] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] =>
)
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] => Array
(
[0] => 1156
[1] => 1154
)
[~DESCRIPTION] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] =>
)
[~NAME] => Модераторы
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[KEYREPORTS] => Array
(
[ID] => 68
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:15:25
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Ключевой доклад
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 50
[CODE] => KEYREPORTS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array
(
[0] => 74662
[1] => 74663
)
[VALUE] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[ID] => 15047
[NAME] => Janet Gornick
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/janet-gornick/
[POSITION] => Professor, City University of New York; Director, Stone Center on Socio-Economic Inequality; Director, US Office, Luxembourg Income Study
[DONOTLINK] => Y
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] =>
)
[1] => Array
(
[ID] => 15048
[NAME] => Filip Novokmet
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/filip-novokmet/
[POSITION] => Research Fellow, World Inequality Lab, Paris School of Economics
[DONOTLINK] => Y
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] =>
)
)
[DESCRIPTION] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] =>
)
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] => Array
(
[0] => 15047
[1] => 15048
)
[~DESCRIPTION] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] =>
)
[~NAME] => Ключевой доклад
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[PARTICIPANTS] => Array
(
[ID] => 53
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:16:15
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Экперты
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 60
[CODE] => PARTICIPANTS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] => 15
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array
(
[0] => 87662
[1] => 87663
[2] => 87664
[3] => 87665
[4] => 87666
[5] => 90413
[6] => 92792
)
[VALUE] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[ID] => 2621
[NAME] => Leonid Borodkin
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/leonid-borodkin/
[POSITION] => Head of the Center for Economic History, Lomonosov Moscow State University
[DONOTLINK] =>
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 3188
)
[1] => Array
(
[ID] => 16386
[NAME] => Kristina Butaeva
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/kristina-butaeva/
[POSITION] => Research Fellow, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology
[DONOTLINK] => Y
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] =>
)
[2] => Array
(
[ID] => 15796
[NAME] => Ruben Enikolopov
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/ruben-enikolopov/
[POSITION] => Rector, NES
[DONOTLINK] => Y
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37010
)
[3] => Array
(
[ID] => 15323
[NAME] => Avner Offer
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/avner-offer/
[POSITION] => Chichele Professor of Economic History, All Souls College, University of Oxford
[DONOTLINK] =>
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 35817
)
[4] => Array
(
[ID] => 2545
[NAME] => Maxim Oreshkin
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/maxim-oreshkin/
[POSITION] => Minister of Economic Development of the Russian Federation
[DONOTLINK] =>
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 3152
)
[5] => Array
(
[ID] => 7410
[NAME] => Lilia Ovcharova
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/liliya-ovcharova/
[POSITION] => Vice Rector, Director of the Institute for Social Policy, National Research University Higher School of Economics
[DONOTLINK] => Y
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37182
)
[6] => Array
(
[ID] => 1199
[NAME] => Natalia Zubarevich
[DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nataliya-zubarevich/
[POSITION] => Professor, Lomonosov Moscow State University
[DONOTLINK] =>
[PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37011
)
)
[DESCRIPTION] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] =>
[2] =>
[3] =>
[4] =>
[5] =>
[6] =>
)
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] => Array
(
[0] => 2621
[1] => 16386
[2] => 15796
[3] => 15323
[4] => 2545
[5] => 7410
[6] => 1199
)
[~DESCRIPTION] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] =>
[2] =>
[3] =>
[4] =>
[5] =>
[6] =>
)
[~NAME] => Экперты
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[MEMBERS] => Array
(
[ID] => 69
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:19
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Участники
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 70
[CODE] => MEMBERS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Участники
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS] => Array
(
[ID] => 72
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:13
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Участники и эксперты
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 80
[CODE] => MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Участники и эксперты
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[KEYREPORT_MODERATOR] => Array
(
[ID] => 115
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:28
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Ключевой доклад/модератор
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 90
[CODE] => KEYREPORT_MODERATOR
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Ключевой доклад/модератор
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[SAY_HIS] => Array
(
[ID] => 246
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-01-15 23:30:57
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Приветствие
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 91
[CODE] => SAY_HIS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Приветствие
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[SPEECH] => Array
(
[ID] => 134
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:48
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Выступления
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 100
[CODE] => SPEECH
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Выступления
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[DISCUSS_MEMBERS] => Array
(
[ID] => 226
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:36:04
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Участники дискуссии
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 101
[CODE] => DISCUSS_MEMBERS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Участники дискуссии
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[AUTHORS] => Array
(
[ID] => 227
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:37:12
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Авторы
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 102
[CODE] => AUTHORS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Авторы
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[LECTORS] => Array
(
[ID] => 228
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:38:09
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Лекторы
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 103
[CODE] => LECTORS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Лекторы
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[PRESENTATIONS] => Array
(
[ID] => 229
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:38:40
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Презентация
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 104
[CODE] => PRESENTATIONS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Презентация
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[SPEAKERS] => Array
(
[ID] => 230
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-22 11:26:55
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Спикеры
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 105
[CODE] => SPEAKERS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Спикеры
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[SUBTITLE] => Array
(
[ID] => 74
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:19:10
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Подзаголовок
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 110
[CODE] => SUBTITLE
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => S
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Подзаголовок
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[MSP_REPRESENTATIVES] => Array
(
[ID] => 78
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:11
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Представители МСП
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 120
[CODE] => MSP_REPRESENTATIVES
[DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array
(
[TEXT] =>
[TYPE] => HTML
)
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => S
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] => HTML
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array
(
[height] => 200
)
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Представители МСП
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array
(
[TEXT] =>
[TYPE] => HTML
)
)
[MEDIA_LINK] => Array
(
[ID] => 135
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-01-16 21:02:27
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Медиаматериалы
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 130
[CODE] => MEDIA_LINK
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 36
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Медиаматериалы
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[CALENDAR] => Array
(
[ID] => 131
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:36
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Календарь
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 140
[CODE] => CALENDAR
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => L
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => C
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 94765
[VALUE] => Да
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] => Да
[VALUE_XML_ID] => cdcbcf72d67def380b63dd8ba1dd146d
[VALUE_SORT] => 500
[VALUE_ENUM_ID] => 39
[~VALUE] => Да
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Календарь
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[EVENT_INFO] => Array
(
[ID] => 132
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:36
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Информационное событие
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 150
[CODE] => EVENT_INFO
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => L
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => C
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[VALUE_ENUM_ID] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Информационное событие
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[CHANGE] => Array
(
[ID] => 133
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:36
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Изменение
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 160
[CODE] => CHANGE
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => L
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => C
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[VALUE_ENUM_ID] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Изменение
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[LANGUAGES] => Array
(
[ID] => 224
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:26:52
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Рабочие языки
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 170
[CODE] => LANGUAGES
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => L
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => C
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array
(
[0] => 94767
[1] => 94766
)
[VALUE] => Array
(
[0] => Russian
[1] => English
)
[DESCRIPTION] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] =>
)
[VALUE_ENUM] => Array
(
[0] => Russian
[1] => English
)
[VALUE_XML_ID] => Array
(
[0] => affb1430ade1dabb9b750ff1961d2505
[1] => 296b3d354b8509e4ce2133793442286c
)
[VALUE_SORT] => Array
(
[0] => 10
[1] => 30
)
[VALUE_ENUM_ID] => Array
(
[0] => 54
[1] => 56
)
[~VALUE] => Array
(
[0] => Russian
[1] => English
)
[~DESCRIPTION] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] =>
)
[~NAME] => Рабочие языки
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[INVITATION_ONLY] => Array
(
[ID] => 225
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-22 18:34:07
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Вход по индивидуальным приглашениям
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 180
[CODE] => INVITATION_ONLY
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => L
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => C
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[VALUE_ENUM_ID] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Вход по индивидуальным приглашениям
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[PREMIUM_ONLY] => Array
(
[ID] => 233
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-22 18:34:07
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Вход с бэйджами категории «ПРЕМИУМ»
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 190
[CODE] => PREMIUM_ONLY
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => L
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => C
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[VALUE_ENUM_ID] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Вход с бэйджами категории «ПРЕМИУМ»
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[KEYNOTE_FILE] => Array
(
[ID] => 239
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2019-01-14 21:47:41
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Доклад
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 200
[CODE] => KEYNOTE_FILE
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => F
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] => pdf
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Доклад
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[OPENINGS] => Array
(
[ID] => 241
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-01-05 18:10:45
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Открытие
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 500
[CODE] => OPENINGS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => E
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => Y
[XML_ID] =>
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] =>
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] =>
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] =>
[VALUE] =>
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] =>
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Открытие
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] =>
)
[KEYNOTE] =>
)
[DISPLAY_PROPERTIES] => Array
(
[QUESTIONS] => Array
(
[ID] => 50
[TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00
[IBLOCK_ID] => 18
[NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения
[ACTIVE] => Y
[SORT] => 10
[CODE] => QUESTIONS
[DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array
(
[TYPE] => HTML
[TEXT] =>
)
[PROPERTY_TYPE] => S
[ROW_COUNT] => 1
[COL_COUNT] => 30
[LIST_TYPE] => L
[MULTIPLE] => N
[XML_ID] => 12
[FILE_TYPE] =>
[MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5
[TMP_ID] =>
[LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0
[WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y
[SEARCHABLE] => N
[FILTRABLE] => N
[IS_REQUIRED] => N
[VERSION] => 1
[USER_TYPE] => HTML
[USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array
(
[height] => 200
)
[HINT] =>
[PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 74361
[VALUE] => Array
(
[TEXT] => <ul class="style-prog-list">
<li>Are both the US and Russia basically high inequality countries?</li>
<li>Do the presented papers provide a credible understanding of income inequality in Russia in the past and at the current moment?</li>
<li>How well do the authors’ data on Russia reflect real living conditions in the regions?</li>
<li>Why did a higher level of social inequality, in comparison with OECD countries, develop in the US?</li>
<li>How well do historical data for Russia compare with historical data for European countries?</li>
</ul>
[TYPE] => HTML
)
[DESCRIPTION] =>
[VALUE_ENUM] =>
[VALUE_XML_ID] =>
[VALUE_SORT] =>
[~VALUE] => Array
(
[TEXT] =>
Are both the US and Russia basically high inequality countries?
Do the presented papers provide a credible understanding of income inequality in Russia in the past and at the current moment?
How well do the authors’ data on Russia reflect real living conditions in the regions?
Why did a higher level of social inequality, in comparison with OECD countries, develop in the US?
How well do historical data for Russia compare with historical data for European countries?
[TYPE] => HTML
)
[~DESCRIPTION] =>
[~NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения
[~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array
(
[TYPE] => HTML
[TEXT] =>
)
[DISPLAY_VALUE] =>
Are both the US and Russia basically high inequality countries?
Do the presented papers provide a credible understanding of income inequality in Russia in the past and at the current moment?
How well do the authors’ data on Russia reflect real living conditions in the regions?
Why did a higher level of social inequality, in comparison with OECD countries, develop in the US?
How well do historical data for Russia compare with historical data for European countries?
This discussion is dedicated to Russian and US income inequality two papers presented: one by Filip Novokmet, Thomas Piketty, and Gabriel Zucman (July 2017), “From Soviets to Oligarchs: Inequality and Property in Russia 1905-2016;” and the other, “American Exceptionalism in Market Income Inequality: An Analysis Based on Microdata from the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) Database,” by Janet C. Gornick, Branko Milanovic, and Nathaniel Johnson (March 2017). One looks at inequality over a very long period, while the other looks at the roots of US "exceptionalism" through the prism of high inequality in the past 30 years.
Leonid Borodkin
Maxim Oreshkin